The AndyGram

Saturday, Jun 03rd

You are here: Home Theatre Reviews & Features 2012-13 Reviews Broadway Review: THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD
Saturday, 15 December 2012 14:20


Written by

If you want to give yourself a gift this holiday season, take yourself to Studio 54 for a bawdy English music hall musical that will knock your socks off. Roundabout Theater Company’s production of The Mystery of Edwin Drood is simply splendid.  Oh sure I have gripes with the book; I find it clumsy and complicated. But let’s face, this is based on a Charles Dickens novel that was never finished. In his unique approach, playwright, composer and lyricist, Rupert Holmes, has the audience vote on who ultimately is the murderer, who is the detective, and who are the lovers.  There is a bounty of delight to be had in this production.

This show has some of the best performances this season. All of the characters playing the Dickinson roles also fall out of character into their role as actors in the music hall production.  For brevity’s sake, I will only refer to them here under the name of their Dickinson role.

Theater goddess, Chita Rivera, is at her best at almost 80 years old. She has a gleam in her eye and the gams of a 17-year-old.  She plays Princess Puffer, the proprietress of an opium den. (She also happened to be voted the killer the night I saw the show. I never thought I would hear Chita Rivera booed on stage.)

Stephanie J Block is handsome as Edwin Drood and you will marvel at her lush and silky voice and commanding presence.  The sprightly Jim Norton as the Chairman, or MC, gives a rapid-fire delivery of corny jokes that you have heard so many times before, and yet, when he delivers them, you still laugh.  When he teams up with Jasper, Edwin Drood’s uncle (played point on by Will Chase), for “Both Sides of the Coin,” the results are popping with plosives.  

Jessie Mueller and Andy Karl are the cosmetically bronzed Helena and Neville Landless, straight off the boat from Ceylon.  They delight with their Bollywood-style arm and hand moves and their pursed lipped sideways glares to the audience.

As Drood’s intended, Rosa Bud, Betsy Wolfe stunningly sings “Moon Fall.”  She then has a great time during the evening’s voting trying to convince everyone that she is herself the killer.  Much to her consternation, the evening I saw it she wound up as one of the two lovers and was paired this evening with the youngest member of the cast, Deputy, the unrefined assistant to the gravedigger, played by the adorable Nicholas Barasch.   Watching them play off one another tickled me.

Also in the cast is Broadway veteran Gregg Edelman as the giddy Reverend Mr. Crisparkle,  Robert Creighton as the disheveled and dingy grave digger, Durdles and Peter Benson, who plays Bazzard.  His music hall character, Mr. Phillip Bax, elicits just the right amount of pity in his never-ending search for a bigger role.  

The Mystery of Edwin Drood is tautly directed by Scott Ellis, yet still allows for the free-spirited casual exchange between the actors playing the Dickinson characters and the audience.  

Studio 54 itself is decked out for the holidays with the boxes on either side of the proscenium festooned in red velvet bunting, replete with holiday greens and period chandeliers.The set itself, frequently nothing more than a simple drop or flat, designed by Anna Louizos provides a retinal rapture when paired with Brian Nason’s subtle and nuanced lighting.  William Ivey Long’s perfectly appointed and lush costumes complete the Dickensian picture.

Holmes's score for The Mystery of Edwin Drood is full of gems, including “Moon Fall,” “The Wages of Sin” and “Off to the Races,” just to name a few of my favorites.  You will leave the theater satisfied, floating on air, and humming the score.  Thank you Roundabout Theatre Company for this delightful musical confectionary holiday gift.

View complete production credits at

Additional Info

  • Theatre: Studio 54
  • Theatre Address: 254 West 54th St. New York, NY 10019
  • Show Style: Musical
  • Previews:: October 19, 2012
  • Opening Night: November 13, 2012
  • Closing: March 10, 2013
Last modified on Saturday, 22 December 2012 15:36