The AndyGram

Saturday, Jun 03rd

You are here: Home Theatre Reviews & Features 2010-11 Reviews Broadway Review: THE NORMAL HEART
Monday, 06 June 2011 22:57

Broadway Review: THE NORMAL HEART

Written by
Joe Montello (l) and John Benjamin Hickey Joe Montello (l) and John Benjamin Hickey Photo: Joan Marcus

When I first moved to New York in the fall of 1982 the AIDS epidemic was already well on its way to becoming the great plague of the 20th Century.  I first heard about AIDS when a friend handed me a pamphlet in a bar.  Little did I know that what my long-time family physician blew off as just another immune deficiency disease would wreak such havoc on the world.

The world owes Larry Kramer a debt of gratitude.  He has made it his life’s mission to make the world aware of the crisis, to help those afflicted and in need and to keep his heel on the neck of the government and the drug companies who weren’t doing the right things.  Not only that, but he passionately and humorously chronicled it in a beautiful piece of story-telling that touches the heart while it drives the point home.  

When the crisis began, then President Ronald Reagan didn't publicly say the word AIDS until seven years into his term.  The plague was allowed to ravage thousands before it began to be treated as the killer it is.  The Normal Heart documents Mr. Kramer’s cry of outrage and was first presented at the Public Theater in 1985.  It is the semi-autobiographical story of Mr. Kramer, his fight and the founding of the Gay Men's Health Crisis.  

Mr. Kramer's alter-ego is Ned Weeks, astonishingly played by Joe Mantello, better known to today's audiences as the director of the smash mega-hit Wicked.  Mr Mantello gives one of the season's best performances (for which he has received a Tony Award nomination.)  Ned's brother is a high-profile lawyer Ben, starchly played by Mark Harelik, who Ned convinces to take on his new fledgling organization as a pro-bono client.

This entire cast is sublime as they bring this crisis to horrifying life.  The talented Ellen Barkin, in her Broadway debut, is Dr. Emma Brookner.  Her character is based on Dr. Linda Laubenstein, a pioneer in the research and treatment of HIV/AIDS who fought passionately for funding for AIDS research.  Barkin gives an intense and passionate performance as the wheelchair-bound doctor who treated gay men with compassion when most folks wouldn't even go near them.  I don’t recall ever seeing an actor receive such sustained applause after a single monologue as Ms. Barkin did the night I saw The Normal Heart.  Barkin pours her guts out at a panel hearing in Washington when she learns she has lost her funding.  Her visceral response in this scene is raw and intense.

John Benjamin Hickey is New York Times style editor Felix Turner who Ned tries to convince to write about what's happening in the gay community.  They wind up lovers with Felix ultimately succumbing to the disease.  Hickey’s performance is marvelous as he goes from healthy, energetic and handsome to weak and sitting on the floor in self-pity.  Rounding out the other colorful and tragic figures in Mr. Kramer's world are Luke MacFarlane ("Brothers and Sisters"), Jim Parsons ("Big Bang Theory") and Lee Pace ("Pushing Daisies").

Co-director’s Joel Grey and George C. Wolfe have stayed true to the simplicity of the original production.  Scenes wax and wane with energy and emotion like a finely crafted piece of music with all the dynamics that make it interesting.  The set by David Rockwell is a simple box set with quotes on the wall that Kramer also details in his notes at the beginning of the script.  These include references to the total number of cases of AIDS, the amounts spent on research by public officials like Mayor Koch and Diane Feinstein, and a quote from the “American Jewry During the Holocaust” report which was prepared for the American Jewish Commission on the Holocaust.  Kramer draws a parallel between the extermination of Jews in 1940s Germany to the crises that public officials in this country willingly let play out in the gay community in the 1980s.  

The Normal Heart can be very funny at times and will make you laugh even while it moves you to tears.  As the names of thousands of dead AIDS patients light up the walls of the set and the interior of the theatre, you could feel the emotion in the theatre as sniffles emanated from throughout the audience.  Do not miss this play, it only runs through July 10, 2011.

As we left the theatre, there stood Larry Kramer passing out a letter that he wrote.  It’s almost a post-script to the play. It's his way of saying, this really happened, these people are gone now, and this is still a plague.  He is fervid in his devotion to this cause.  I have attached a copy of Mr. Kramer’s letter to this review.  Read it and you will understand what I mean.

Read the entire production credits at

Additional Info

  • Theatre: Golden Theatre
  • Theatre Address: 252 West 45th St. New York, NY 10036
  • Show Style: Play
  • Previews:: April 19, 2011
  • Opening Night: April 27, 2011
  • Closing: July 10, 2011
Last modified on Thursday, 09 July 2015 02:48